4.5 stars.I know from skimming through the reviews that lots of people really hated this book.I quite liked it. The hero was the typical HP cave man who thought nothing of his double standards. But, what made this book for me was the growth of his awareness and love of the heroine. It was not a last chapter redemption. He evolved throughout the course of the story making his transformation very real and believable.I totally felt the HEA was genuine.